Bailout Scorecard PDF Print E-mail
Written by Administrator   
Thursday, 07 January 2010 17:39

The bailout so far totals nearly $2 trillion in aid and guarantees to banks and housing market support.  Here is an accounting of all the main bailout programs, along with the possible potential loss of each.  If the housing market falls modestly, the taxpayer stands to lose at least $1.1 trillion, not just from the bailout funds, but from losses from government mortgage guarantees.

 

Most of the bailout money is in the form of loans and guarantees, so if all goes well, losses will be low.  The best case scenario is a loss of $150 billion in 'Giveaways' (see below). However, in addition to bailout loans, the government also guarantees GSE-related debt.  So if the housing market continues to fall, then assuming a 10% loss in housing price securities, the taxpayer stands to lose $1.1 trillion (sum of 'Loss' and 'Giveaway').  This number could be much higher if the housing market falls further, or if the government pours more money into the bailout.

 

Not included are a small number of smaller bailout programs (less than $5 billion).  As well, this list doesn't include stimulus spending, which is about $700 billion.  All dollar amounts below are in billions.

 

The amounts below are current as of January 7, 2010.

 

Capital Purchases

These are the large purchases of stock by the government with the resulting percentage ownership in the company. The government also provided capital to thousands of banks under TARP, but most of that money has been returned, with the exception of $25 billion from Citigroup. Although the companies are required to pay back the government eventually, there is no indication that any of these companies will be able to do so any time soon. Our optimistic estimate is that the taxpayer will be repaid 50%. All amounts in billions.

 



Percentage owned by government
AIG $40 80%
GM $53 61%
Chrysler $14 10%
GMAC $17 56%
Citigroup $25 26%



Total $148
Loss (50%) $74

 

Mortgage Purchases and Guarantees

The government owns or guarantees about $7 trillion in home mortgage assets. Also, it continues to purchase more mortgages and mortgage obligations since Sept 2008 to provide more cash for the housing market. This activity keeps house prices high and mortgage rates low. How long the government will continue to support the market in this way remains to be seen. If housing prices fall significantly, the government (i.e. The taxpayer) will be on the hook for billions of dollars. The liability estimate here assumes housing prices will continue to fall, resulting in a 10% loss in the portfolios. Technically the government is responsible only for FHA insurance. However, in practice it backs the bonds and insured securities of all GSEs as well.

 

Guarantees on GSE mortgages

 

FNMA Fannie Mae bonds $800 Outstanding Bonds
FDMC Freddie Mac bonds $700 Outstanding Bonds
FNMA Fannie Mae guarantees $2,400 Guarantees on MBS owned by third parties
FDMC Freddie Mac guarantees $1,500 Guarantees on MBS owned by third parties
FHLB Federal Home Loan Banks $1,150 FHLB mortgages (implicit guarantee on FHLB bonds)
FHA Federal Housing Administration $725 Insurance on mortgage loans




Total
$7,275
Loss (10%)
$728

 

Federal purchase of private MBS

The government has also purchased $500 billion of private-label MBS (non-GSE MBS) from banks to support the housing market, avoid failures of certain big businesses, and increase credit liquidity.

 




current maximum


Bank of American loan-loss backstop Treas, Fed & FDIC $118 $118
Government backing of assets from Merrill Lynch merger in exchange for fees & shares
TAF Term auction facility Fed $200 $450
Purchase MBS from banks for short term 1-3 month cash

AIG TARP $50 $50
MBOs bought from GS and other banks to cancel AIG's CDS contracts
TSLF Term securities lending facility Fed $30 $200
Exchange MBS for gov't securities (1 month)

Bear Stearns bailout Fed $29 $29
Toxic assets now managed by BlackRock, sold over time
PPIP Public-Private Investment Program Treas $20 $30
Joint program to create MBO purchasing investment vehicles – 50-50 pubic money and private money. Principal can be wiped out under 6x leverage.
PPIP Public-Private Investment Program FDIC $0 $240
PPIP issues FDIC guaranteed debt







Total

$447 $1,117

Loss (10%)

$45 $112

 

Fed Repurchases

The Fed is purchasing assets from GSEs in order to provide liquidity for more loans, to continue to support housing prices and keep interest rates low. However, this does not increase the government's liability since these loans are guaranteed by GSEs and may be held until maturity.

 

GSE MBS purchases Fed $1,100 $1,250 Purchase MBOs from Fannie & Freddie & Ginnie (to be completed March 2010). In the case of default it is unknown if the Fed will request payment from F&F.
GSE direct debt purchases Fed $100 $100 Purchase Fannie & Freddie, FHLB bonds

 

Housing Market Giveaways

These programs are simple tax credits or cash giveaways. There is no expectation of repayment.

 



current maximum
MHA Making Home Affordable $27 $75 Payments to servicers & GSEs to renegotiate mortgages (refinance, extend, or reduce principal)
FTHBC Homebuyer credit $14 $20 Homebuyer credits up to $8000/home through March 2010
FDIC FDIC bailout 0 $1000 The FDIC has unlimited liability to resolve failed banks, but its insurance fund is under $40 billion. Currently large banks like Bank of American and Citigroup are zombies, and will probably never return to solvency. When they finally fail, they will require huge government infusions to pay back insured deposits.
F&F Fannie & Freddie bailout $110 $400 Unlimited funding to keep them solvent: Preferred stock purchase agreement likely to be as much as $400 billion





Loss
$151 $1495

 

 

Future Expenditures

These are programs that are in the government toolkit, and could be implemented in a future crisis.

 

Credit union deposit insurance guarantees

Money market guarantee
This program covers previously uninsured money market funds. It was implemented temporarily in October 2008.

 

 

Bank Liquidity Guarantees

These programs guarantee bank operations so that investors will feel safer when purchasing bank bonds or making deposits. The loss assumes 10%, since not all banks will survive the current financial environment.

 




current maximum
FDW Fed discount window Fed
unlimited Very low borrowing rates for banks which can be invested in risky assets (carry trade)
TLGP DGP Temporary Liquidity Guarantee Program - Debt Guarantee Program FDIC $313
FDIC guarantee of debt issued by 57 banks, e.g. Goldman Sachs
TLGP TAGP TGLP - Transaction Account Guarantee Program FDIC $760
FDIC guarantee of accounts over $250,000 through June 2010
AIG AIG loans Fed $43 $60 Loans that AIG is expected to repay (recently they proposed giving Fed $25b of it's subsidiaries of unknown value)
TALF Term asset-backed securities loan facility

$200 1 month loans for asset-backed securities like credit cards






Total

$1116

Loss

$111
Last Updated on Friday, 08 January 2010 17:02
 
Copyright © 2010 decouple.org. All Rights Reserved.
 

 Policies

End the FDIC
How to end the FDIC.
Kill the MITD
The Mortgage Interest Tax Deduction is very destructive and must be ended. Here's why.
Dismantle the ratings agency cartel

The government-chartered cartel was a central contributor to the financial crisis. It must be dismantled.


 Background

How to prevent a bank run
To prevent a bank run, banks can temporarily restrict cash withdrawals.
The cause of the financial crisis
The financial crisis was caused by a combination of government policies and regulations.
Bailout Scorecard

$2 trillion in bailouts and counting. Potential losses of at least $1.1 trillion.